There is a rumor going around mid coast Maine that a certain celebrity TV chef, known for trying to out do local chefs at their particular specialty, has come to our area and left with his tail between his legs after trying to improve on the popular Lobster Salad Roll.
Im not at all surprised. You see folks "from away" are always trying to improve on Lobster Salad. They try to put "things" in it like fancy mayonnaise or celery or worse. They don't understand that Lobster is perfect just the way it is and that the secret of lobster is to eat it in its simplest form. If you choose to have a boiled lobster you don't have to put mustard in the water or special spices (as I've, shudder, seen some do) and if you are having a Lobster Salad Roll you really want as little as possible to come between your tongue and the flavor of the lobster.
So as a public service, Maine Coast Properties blog will give you the correct way (read: Maine way) to make a Lobster Salad Roll.
It should go with out saying that you begin with fresh Lobster. The best way to do this is to go visit your local lobsterman at the docks and purchase those lobsters directly from him. Unless of course during the winter he borrowed your chainsaw and wrecked it, in which case he owes you and no money will be changing hands. If you do not have a favorite lobsterman (hard to believe but it happens) you can go to any one of many fine local sea food markets here in the mid coast region of Maine and get your lobsters there. Many people will argue passionately that smaller lobsters are more tender than the large ones. Some will argue that the soft shell lobsters (those that have recently shed) have sweeter meat. I will argue just as passionately that all lobsters as long as they are fresh caught are equally as good, it's more of a function of how you cook them. Some people have a tendency to over cook the hard shell lobsters or the bigger ones and that will lead to a slight toughening of the meat. There's no such thing as a bad lobster, only bad lobster cooks.
Lets assume that you are reasonably intelligent (you are after all reading this blog) and can cook and clean your lobster successfully. So you now have a bowl of lobster meat cut into bite size pieces and slightly chilled. To this you should add just a small amount of mayonnaise, just enough to get some on all of the meat in the bowl. This should be regular store bought mayonnaise not anything fancy and with no other flavoring mixed in. Plain mayonnaise. This next part is a little controversial but I have seen it go both ways and it can work. It's not absolutely necessary. But, should you so desire you can add just the slightest, smallest drop of lemon juice at this point. Two drops would be too much. Now, set that all aside and let the taste of the lobster permeate the mayonnaise. You want to taste lobster not mayonnaise after all.
While you're waiting, prepare the rolls. Again, simplicity is the key. Here in Maine we know that the only permissible roll is a Nissen's brand hot dog roll. No other will do, just a simple Nissen's hot dog roll. Put a little butter on each side and grill it to a golden brown. Take it off the grill or out of the frying pan and while it's still warm stuff it with fresh lobster salad. Nothing else. No lettuce. Lobster Salad.
The essence of a Lobster Salad Roll is the chilled lobster salad and the hot buttered roll. That's all. Perfection personified.
No celebrity chef or fancy restaurant can improve on that. Come visit us and see for yourself.
Jim Cosgrove
Recent Comments